How to Set New Year Intentions Instead of Resolutions: A Gentler Plan That Works
Resolutions tend to be rigid, all-or-nothing promises. Intentions describe who you want to be and how you want to feel, then translate into small, flexible actions, which makes them easier to keep and to restart.
In this article
- Why resolutions often fail
- Most fade over time
- Common traps
- What is an intention?
- The fresh start effect
- A step-by-step method
- Step 1: Look back first
- Step 2: Connect to your values
- Step 3: Choose one to three intentions
- Step 4: Translate each into a tiny action
- Step 5: Plan for obstacles (WOOP / if-then)
- Step 6: Decide how you’ll restart
- Step 7: Schedule check-ins
- Step 8: Share and support
- Examples of intentions with actions
- A worked example
- Common mistakes
- When to seek help
- Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between intentions and resolutions?
- Do New Year’s resolutions work?
- How many intentions should I set?
- How do I turn an intention into action?
- What if I fail?
- Do I have to start on January 1?
- The bottom line
Key takeaways
- In a classic study of New Year's resolvers, success dropped sharply over time, with only a minority still maintaining their resolution after two years.
- People are more motivated at 'fresh start' dates such as the new year, making it a useful moment to begin, but motivation fades without a plan.
- Intentions connected to values, paired with specific if-then plans and mental contrasting of obstacles, are more likely to turn into action.
- Choose one to three intentions, pair each with a tiny first step, expect slips and decide in advance how you'll restart.
Every January you promise yourself: lose weight, save money, exercise every day, stop procrastinating. By mid-February, the promise has quietly vanished and you feel a little worse than before you made it.
The problem often isn’t you; it’s the form. A rigid, all-or-nothing resolution leaves no room for real life. An intention, paired with small actions and a plan for slipping, can work much better.
Why resolutions often fail
Most fade over time
John Norcross and colleagues followed people who made New Year’s resolutions and compared them with similar people who wanted to change but didn’t make resolutions. After one week, the large majority of resolvers were still on track. After one month, about half were. By six months, roughly 40 percent were, and after two years, about one in five was still succeeding. Resolvers did better than non-resolvers, so resolutions weren’t useless, but most faded without ongoing support.
Common traps
- Too big and vague: “Get fit” or “be happier.”
- All-or-nothing rules: one slip equals failure.
- Outcome-only goals: “Lose 10 kilos” with no behaviour plan.
- Borrowed goals: driven by pressure or comparison, not your values. Edward Deci and Richard Ryan’s self-determination theory shows that motivation lasts longer when goals are autonomous, aligned with what you actually value.
- Too many at once: willpower is limited.
- No plan for obstacles: January enthusiasm doesn’t survive a tired Wednesday.
- Shame and self-criticism: punishing yourself undermines persistence. See how to stop being so hard on yourself.
What is an intention?
An intention is a statement of how you want to live, act or feel, a direction rather than a finish line. For example:
| Resolution | Intention |
|---|---|
| “Lose 10 kilos” | “I intend to care for my body with steady, enjoyable movement and nourishing food.” |
| “Save $5,000” | “I intend to spend in line with what I value.” |
| “Never procrastinate again” | “I intend to start important things earlier and kindly.” |
| “Go to the gym 5 times a week” | “I intend to make movement a regular part of my days.” |
Intentions are broader and more flexible, can be revisited anytime (daily, monthly or yearly) and focus on the person you’re becoming. On their own, though, they can be vague. The key is to pair them with concrete actions.
The fresh start effect
Hengchen Dai, Katherine Milkman and Jason Riis found that people are more likely to pursue goals right after temporal landmarks such as the start of a new year, month, week or birthday, because these dates feel like a fresh chapter and create psychological distance from past failures. Google searches for “diet” and gym attendance rose at these points. So the new year is a good moment to begin, but the effect fades, so you need a plan to keep going. You can also create your own fresh starts: the first of any month, a Monday, your birthday.
A step-by-step method
Step 1: Look back first
Before looking ahead, take stock of the year behind you: what worked, what drained you, what you learned. See how to do a personal year-end review. Your intentions will be wiser if they grow from what you’ve learned.
Step 2: Connect to your values
Ask: What matters most to me right now? Who do I want to be? How do I want to feel more often? Write a few answers. See how to find your core values. Intentions rooted in your own values keep their pull when motivation dips.
Step 3: Choose one to three intentions
Fewer is better. Write each as a short sentence starting with “I intend to…” or choose a word of the year (such as “steady,” “gentle,” “curious,” “present”) that captures the theme. Check that each is something you want, not what you think you should want.
Step 4: Translate each into a tiny action
For each intention, choose a small, specific behaviour that you can do within a few minutes, and a cue. Example:
- Intention: “I intend to care for my body with steady movement.”
- Action: “After I make my coffee, I’ll walk for 10 minutes.”
Start smaller than you think. See how habits actually form and how to start a daily stretching habit.
Step 5: Plan for obstacles (WOOP / if-then)
Gabriele Oettingen’s research on mental contrasting shows that combining a positive vision with a realistic look at the obstacles, then making an if-then plan, produces better follow-through than positive fantasies alone. This is the idea behind her method “WOOP”: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan. For each intention, ask:
- What is the main obstacle? (I’ll be tired after work.)
- If that happens, what will I do? (If I’m tired, then I’ll do five minutes of stretching.)
Peter Gollwitzer’s work on implementation intentions supports this approach.
Step 6: Decide how you’ll restart
Expect slips and decide now: “If I miss a day, I’ll resume the next day with the smallest version. If I miss a week, I’ll review and adjust.” The restart plan is what makes an intention resilient. See how to make a habit stick after a relapse.
Step 7: Schedule check-ins
Put a short review in your calendar at the end of each week or month: What worked? What got in the way? What small change would help? Adjust your actions. Edwin Locke and Gary Latham’s research on goal setting emphasises feedback as part of success.
Step 8: Share and support
Tell a friend or partner about your intention and ask them to check in. Social support can sustain motivation. Avoid public pressure that turns into shame.
Examples of intentions with actions
| Intention | Tiny action | If-then plan |
|---|---|---|
| “I intend to rest without guilt.” | “Each evening, 20 minutes without screens.” | “If I feel guilty, I’ll name it and stay for five minutes.” |
| “I intend to be more present.” | “Phone in a drawer during dinner.” | “If I reach for my phone, I’ll take a breath and ask a question.” |
| “I intend to say no more kindly.” | “Wait a day before agreeing to requests.” | “If I’m pressured, I’ll say, ‘Let me check and get back to you.’” |
| “I intend to connect.” | “One message to a friend each week.” | “If I feel too busy, I’ll send a voice note.” |
| “I intend to look after my money.” | “Check my accounts on Sunday for 10 minutes.” | “If I feel anxious, I’ll do it with a cup of tea.” |
A worked example
Maya usually makes five resolutions and drops them by February.
- Look back: last year, she was overcommitted and exhausted.
- Values: she values health, connection and calm.
- Intentions: she chooses two: “I intend to protect my energy” and “I intend to stay connected with people I love.”
- Actions: a walk after work three days a week, and a weekly call with a friend.
- Obstacles: tiredness and busyness; if-then plans: “If I’m tired, I’ll walk for five minutes,” “If I’m busy, I’ll send a voice note.”
- Restart: “If I miss a week, I’ll start again on Monday.”
- Check-in: every Sunday for ten minutes.
- Support: she tells her sister.
By March, both intentions are still alive, flexible and real.
Common mistakes
- Choosing too many intentions. One to three.
- Making them vague with no actions. Add small steps.
- Setting goals from guilt or comparison. Start with values.
- Ignoring obstacles. Plan for them.
- Treating a slip as failure. Restart.
- Waiting for January 1. Any day can be a fresh start.
When to seek help
Consider talking to a therapist or doctor if:
- you feel intense pressure, shame or hopelessness around changes you want to make,
- you struggle to start or follow through because of low mood, anxiety or exhaustion,
- your goals relate to eating, weight or exercise and feel obsessive or distressing,
- you have difficulty with focus or planning that has long affected your life, which may suggest ADHD,
- you have thoughts of harming yourself.
If you are in crisis, contact your local emergency number or, in the United States, call or text 988. See how to stop feeling stuck in life and our disclaimer.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between intentions and resolutions?
Resolutions are specific, often rigid promises; intentions describe a direction or way of being and are more flexible.
Do New Year’s resolutions work?
Some do. Research shows resolvers fare better than non-resolvers, but most fade over time without a plan and support.
How many intentions should I set?
One to three. Fewer is easier to remember and act on.
How do I turn an intention into action?
Pair it with a tiny action tied to a cue, plan for obstacles and schedule check-ins.
What if I fail?
Slips are normal. Decide in advance how you’ll restart, and treat setbacks as information.
Do I have to start on January 1?
No. Fresh starts can be any day, such as a Monday, the first of a month or your birthday.
The bottom line
Resolutions often fail because they’re rigid and unplanned. Intentions grow from your values and become real through tiny actions, plans for obstacles and a ready restart. Look back, choose one to three intentions, translate them into small steps and check in often. A gentler start can last longer.
References & sources
- Auld Lang Syne: Success predictors, change processes, and self-reported outcomes of New Year's resolvers and nonresolvers . Journal of Clinical Psychology, 58(4), 397–405 (Norcross, Mrykalo & Blagys), 2002.
- The fresh start effect: Temporal landmarks motivate aspirational behavior . Management Science, 60(10), 2563–2582 (Dai, Milkman & Riis), 2014.
- Future thought and behaviour change . European Review of Social Psychology, 23(1), 1–63 (Oettingen), 2012.
- Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being . American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78 (Ryan & Deci), 2000.
This article is for general information and education. It is not medical advice and cannot replace care from a qualified professional. Read our disclaimer.
Related reading
How to Set Goals and Actually Stick to Them: A 9-Step Guide
Most goals fail not because you lack willpower, but because of how they were set. Here is how to choose goals that matter, make them concrete and build a plan that survives real life.
How to Do a Personal Year-End Review: A 6-Step Reflection That Actually Helps
A year-end review is not a performance appraisal of yourself. It is a structured look back that helps you notice what mattered, what to keep, what to stop and what you learned before you set new goals.
How to Find Your Core Values: A 5-Step Exercise to Decide What Matters
Values are not rules or goals. They are the qualities you want your life to express. Knowing yours makes decisions simpler, explains why some things drain you and gives direction when goals feel unclear.
More in Personal Growth
All Personal Growth →
Editor’s picks
The Clear Mind letter
One considered essay, now and then.
No streaks, no urgency. A short note when we publish something worth your attention.